Teenage Wildlife

IMPORTANT: Use your registry nickname as your username when logging in to Conversation Piece!


BowieTalk
   >> Views and Questions
Thread views: 1072 Flat Mode*

Earthling on Fire
(kook)
10/17/03 07:25 AM
Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances [re: Adam]  

At this point I'd like to address the commonly received idea that Garson's piano work is more or less akin to that of Cecil Taylor.
Among pianists I would suggest he is closer (closest?) to Thelonious Monk, but there are major differences too. Monk's music was so much his own that he could not be an accompanist, and his music had much more to do with silence than Garson's does. To a certain extent Garson might be to Taylor what Coltrane was to Ornette Coleman.
Taylor's playing is mostly atonal, while Garson's, I feel, most of the time starts from a definite key, melody and rhythm and then subverts and twists them to change them into something completely different, in a way that feels perfectly logical. There are no gaps or leaps in his playing. You can hear he is transforming a tune from within, not taking foreign elements into it.
I lack the musical training to describe this more precisely but I can hear it for instance in the studio versions of Aladdin Sane and I'm Deranged, also in the version of A Small Plot of Land Adam has just given us - and eternal thanks to him for it.
I think this is why there is such a strong connection between Bowie and Garson: transforming his music and himself without solution of continuity is what Bowie achieved in the 1970s.

Wear your wound with honour.


 
Entire thread
Subject  Posted byPosted on
*Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  AdamModerator02/04/02 06:21 AM
.*A small plot of land in my hand.  SysiyoModerator02/02/05 08:37 AM
.*Re: A small plot of land in my hand.  diamondogz7402/02/05 10:31 AM
..Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  Earthling on Fire10/17/03 07:25 AM
.*Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  ghostlove02/02/05 10:24 AM
.*Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  Dara02/02/05 04:55 PM
.*Funny how secrets travel...  ghostlove02/03/05 04:40 AM
.*Download  AdamModerator10/17/03 01:54 AM
.*Re: Download  MellowThighedChick10/17/03 12:31 PM
.*Re: Download  bowiefanpeter10/17/03 04:42 AM
.*completism  AdamModerator10/17/03 06:24 AM
.*Re: completism  guiltpuppy02/02/05 06:58 PM
.*Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  sonofsilence02/12/02 02:24 AM
.*Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  bowiefanpeter02/12/02 02:06 AM
.*Re: Bowie and Garson Duo Performances  Goblin Queen02/04/02 07:53 AM
.*The Garson Album  AdamModerator02/04/02 09:21 PM
.*The Bowie/Garson Dream  WildWind02/11/02 07:28 PM
.*Re: The Bowie/Garson Dream  AdamModerator10/17/03 01:48 AM
.*Re: The Bowie/Garson Dream  dice02/11/02 10:02 PM
Jump to

Teenage Wildlife Davie Bowie | Email Us! Forums powered by WWWThreads v5.1.5perl

Teenage Wildlife Home Page Bowie's music Info on Bowie Other Media Have your say! Search the Site Help me!


Toolbar (Interact)

Etete Systems