Teenage Wildlife

IMPORTANT: Use your registry nickname as your username when logging in to Conversation Piece!


BowieTalk
   >> Views and Questions
Thread views: 5543 Flat Mode*

ziggfried
(acolyte)
03/13/07 10:13 PM
Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili [re: K]  

In reply to:

I dunno, I don't think Word on a Wing or even Stay are that different from the stuff on YA


As JonnyManic pointed out on a recent thread, "Stay" is basically a re-write of "John, I'm Only Dancing (Again)" (which we can classify as a Young Americans track by virtue of the fact that it was recorded during the same sessions and was for a time set for inclusion on the album). Might we even assume that "JIOD(A)" didn't make the cut because Bowie wanted to overhaul it and make it into a new song on the next album? What would that say about the contintuity between YA and STS?

The only STS tracks I can't see fitting in with YA are the title track and "TVC 15."




 
Entire thread
Subject  Posted byPosted on
*How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   MaxwellS02/24/07 08:53 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/14/07 01:31 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Claude03/13/07 09:44 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/07/07 07:54 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Emil03/09/07 04:34 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 07:27 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Emil03/09/07 07:40 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 08:17 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/09/07 09:24 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/09/07 10:28 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/09/07 11:37 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 12:15 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/09/07 04:47 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 09:18 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/09/07 10:03 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 10:25 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/10/07 07:53 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator03/10/07 07:08 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/10/07 10:46 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator03/10/07 12:31 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Emil03/10/07 12:37 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/10/07 12:54 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   MaxwellS03/16/07 06:00 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/10/07 09:07 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/20/07 01:04 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/11/07 12:13 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/13/07 09:07 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Adam03/13/07 09:39 AM
.*Again, this has little relation to Young Emilicans  KModerator03/13/07 12:25 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emilicans  BigFatDog03/13/07 12:55 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emilicans  bowiefanpeter03/16/07 06:45 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  KModerator03/13/07 01:27 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  BigFatDog03/13/07 07:06 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  KModerator03/13/07 07:32 PM
.*You're a sole man  theidiot203/14/07 10:38 AM
.*Re: You're a sole man  KModerator03/14/07 02:40 PM
..Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  ziggfried03/13/07 10:13 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  russellmael03/14/07 05:54 AM
.*STATIONTOSTATION  EuropeanCanon03/21/07 02:06 PM
.*Re: STATIONTOSTATION  theidiot203/22/07 05:36 AM
.*Re: STATIONTOSTATION  KModerator03/21/07 04:04 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  BigFatDog03/14/07 09:54 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  ziggfried03/14/07 04:55 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  MaxwellS03/16/07 05:58 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  BigFatDog03/14/07 06:42 PM
.*Please change the subject line already  Emil03/15/07 08:28 AM
.*Re: Please change the subject line already  ziggfried03/15/07 10:06 AM
.*Re: Please change the subject line already  Emil03/15/07 10:29 AM
.*The Emil-rads  KModerator03/15/07 11:31 AM
.*Re: The Emil-rads  ziggfried03/15/07 11:24 PM
.*Re: The Emil-rads  KModerator03/16/07 03:09 AM
.*"Listen everybody, especially you girls"  theidiot203/15/07 10:04 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  ziggfried03/15/07 00:18 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  KModerator03/15/07 06:43 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  ziggfried03/15/07 10:01 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  KModerator03/14/07 09:31 PM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  KModerator03/14/07 09:13 AM
.*Re: Again, this has little relation to Young Emili  BigFatDog03/13/07 08:30 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   MaxwellS03/12/07 07:25 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/12/07 10:27 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/12/07 11:04 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ghostlove03/12/07 12:07 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Forgotten_Boy03/13/07 03:28 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator03/13/07 06:12 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator03/12/07 05:19 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator03/11/07 07:28 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/11/07 08:13 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter03/10/07 07:38 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 10:58 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried03/09/07 09:40 AM
.*important album  Emil02/26/07 03:32 PM
.*Re: important album  MaxwellS03/12/07 07:13 AM
.*Re: important album  schizophrenic02/26/07 06:03 PM
.*Re: important album  Mxy02/26/07 06:15 PM
.*Re: important album  ziggfried02/26/07 06:03 PM
.*Re: important album  theidiot202/27/07 06:29 AM
.*Re: important album  bowiefanpeter02/27/07 09:27 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Froggy Starlust02/24/07 12:09 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Modesty_Blaise02/24/07 09:11 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator02/24/07 11:56 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   Modesty_Blaise02/24/07 12:50 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator02/25/07 10:34 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   kingsteved02/24/07 11:31 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   bowiefanpeter02/25/07 04:23 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried02/25/07 05:07 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried02/24/07 11:57 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   KModerator02/24/07 12:06 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   ziggfried02/24/07 12:22 PM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Americans?   BigFatDog03/03/07 07:54 AM
.*Re: How does Bowie rate Young Emil?   KModerator03/03/07 09:05 AM
Jump to

Teenage Wildlife Davie Bowie | Email Us! Forums powered by WWWThreads v5.1.5perl

Teenage Wildlife Home Page Bowie's music Info on Bowie Other Media Have your say! Search the Site Help me!


Toolbar (Interact)

Etete Systems